Skip to content

What 100 insurance advertisers run in ChatGPT today

Alex Moura Co-Founder and CEO of Digital Star Marketing. Fractional CMO for insurtech and MGA teams, with hands-on experience in paid media and HubSpot attribution. Published · Updated
A marketing analyst in her twenties pins printed ad examples onto a cork board in neat rows, sleeves pushed up. A wall of printed ad cards sorted into groups with lime and lavender tape, two people stepping back to look at it.

Three public ad libraries hold 405 insurance ads from 100 advertisers. Carriers wrote the most, 169. But when someone names a brand, comparison sites and media brands usually win the card. And about a quarter of the questions behind these ads never say “insurance” at all, though about 100 of those name an insurer.

Ads Manager shows you nothing about your competitors’ ChatGPT ads, and nothing about the prompts behind them.

Who is advertising?

Carriers wrote the most creatives. The single most-shown advertiser is a comparison site. NEXT Insurance and ERGO NEXT Insurance count as one advertiser, because they are one company.

Advertiser typeCreativesWhat they write
Carriers: 157, plus ERGO NEXT’s 12169Benefit lines: “Bundle Policies and Save With GEICO”, “Reimburse Vet Bills”, “Get a quote in a few taps”
Comparison sites112Match lines: “Insurance near you, find local providers ready to help” (EverQuote, shown 493 times)
Media brands79List lines: “Best 5 Value Pet Plans 2026”, “10 Best Auto & Home Insurance 2026”
Agencies25Local and line-specific offers
Not classified for sure20A carrier, agency or broker we could not confirm from the name alone
Total405100 advertisers

Scale is concentrated. On gptadlibrary’s October capture, EverQuote (933 ads shown), GEICO (510) and The Zebra (472) took 31.5% of the 6,075 ads it recorded on insurance questions. GEICO alone runs 45 distinct copies. Allianz, BestMoney, New York Life, Forbes and NerdWallet are also in the top ten, alongside Jotform and Event Helper. For a regional carrier, those are the cards to beat.

Insurers won 2 of 16 live ads

In 22 live answers to insurance and life-moment questions in October, 16 carried an ad. Insurers won 2, Ethos and ERGO NEXT. Comparison sites won 7: NerdWallet three times, Forbes twice, BestMoney and a travel comparison site once each. LLC services, a home warranty, a coding course and movers took the rest.

  • The answer names insurers before any ad. On renters, pet and travel questions, ChatGPT listed insurers itself, some with quote buttons. The paid card sits under all of it.
  • The ad follows the topic, not the industry. A burst-pipe question drew a home warranty ad. Renters questions drew a comparison site’s car and home ads. No renters insurer won a renters question.
  • Delivery is uneven. Half the first questions in a new chat drew an ad. The same cyber question drew an ad one day and none the next.
Two screenshots from one ChatGPT renters chat on an iPhone: the answer lists Lemonade, State Farm and Allstate with links under Where I would get quotes, then the ad card that followed, NerdWallet’s Compare Car Insurance
A renters chat: three insurers named in the answer, then a comparison site’s car insurance ad. Screenshots in this chapter are from ChatGPT in October 2026; each ad belongs to its advertiser.

How comparison sites win the card, and how to get on their lists

Forbes won two of the seven comparison-site ads, and its pages show how the model works.

  1. The card sells research. “Our Top 9 Life Insurance Picks” appeared after ChatGPT’s life insurance quiz. It speaks to someone still comparing, not someone ready to quote with one insurer.
  2. The ad leads to an affiliate comparison page. It is a Forbes Advisor page with scores, badges and “See Plans” buttons. Its disclosure: “We earn a commission from the offers on this page, which impacts their display.”
  3. Partners hold the top spots. On the life page, Ethos is #1, “People’s Top Pick” with a 9.8, and again in a sticky bar. On the travel page, Faye is first, “Most Popular,” with its own pop-up and sticky bar. Every partner gets a score and a “Best for” badge.
  4. Affiliate links connect the sale to the page. The buttons run through affiliate networks such as Impact and CJ and pass along Forbes’ click ID and the page the click came from.

For an insurer, the lists work as a paid channel:

  • Get on the lists. Forbes Advisor’s comparison pages run on affiliate and partner deals, like the ones Ethos and Faye have, and Forbes discloses that its commissions affect how offers appear.
  • Play both sides, as Ethos does. Ethos is #1 on Forbes’ life list and runs its own ChatGPT ads. It won the first answer of the same life chat, one answer before Forbes’ card.
  • Ask for reporting by source. Have the publisher report which of your sales came from its ChatGPT traffic.
  • Match the hand-off. Ethos sends Forbes visitors to a co-branded page, “Ethos + Forbes Advisor.”
  • Judge on sold policies. A comparison-site lead can be cheaper and earlier. Your sales data decides whether it is better.
A Forbes ad card in ChatGPT on an iPhone: Our Top 9 Life Insurance Picks, Compare our 2026 top life insurance picks, with a photo of a family on a sofa
Forbes’ card after a life insurance answer.

An insurer won the price question

In one small-business chat, LLC services took the first two ad cards. When the chat turned to “how much,” ERGO NEXT’s card appeared, with “Construction insurance starting from $29/month” in the image. The next three cards went back to LLC services and a coding course.

ERGO NEXT’s ads in the sample came from pricing-themed ad groups, Cost-Pricing-Contractors and Cost-Pricing-Business, and appeared on price questions such as “how much” and “who offers the best rates.”

Build an insurer’s first campaign the same way: one ad group per line for cost questions (“how much,” “what does it cost,” “cheapest”), with the price question as the one to win.

Three ad cards from one ChatGPT chat on an iPhone, in order: Tailor Brands, Upgrade to an LLC Today; LegalZoom, Start Your LLC in Minutes; ERGO NEXT Insurance, See Your Insurance Cost, with Construction insurance starting from $29/month in the image
One landscaping chat, in order. Only the price question drew an insurer.

What ERGO NEXT’s ads reveal

ERGO NEXT appeared on small-business insurance questions more than any other insurer in the live answers. In one of those chats, the answer itself named Hiscox, The Hartford, Chubb and Coalition, and ERGO NEXT bought the card under it. Being named in the answer and buying the card are separate decisions.

A real ChatGPT ad card captured on October 27, 2026: the line This might also interest you, then ERGO NEXT Insurance, Small Business Insurance, Instant quotes from top local brokers online, with a Starting from $19/month panel and a grey Ad label
ERGO NEXT’s card under a small-business question.

Its ad links to a dedicated landing page, not the homepage, and tags the visit as ChatGPT traffic. The page has an industry picker (construction, food and beverage, retail, cleaning), a 4.7 out of 5 rating from 5,056 reviews, “750,000+” customers, partner logos, four awards, and the ad’s “Prices start at just $19/month for general liability,” with a footnote that starting prices are existing premiums as of April 1, 2026 and not guaranteed. Every button goes to the quote flow. It names no issuing carrier and has no form on the page.

Copy the shape: a dedicated URL, an industry picker, a rating, the matching price with its footnote. Add what it lacks: the issuing carrier, your license line and a short form.

Who wins when someone names a brand?

221 of the 1,279 prompts named an insurer. On those, the named brand’s own ad appeared 23 times. A rival carrier appeared 68 times. A comparison site or media brand, 140 times. Most of the named brands, such as State Farm, USAA and Allstate, did not appear as advertisers in the sample at all.

GEICO appeared most often on rival brands: 12 of 28 State Farm prompts, 8 of 35 Progressive prompts, 5 of 10 USAA prompts, 4 of 13 Allstate prompts. BestMoney is the most frequent third party on every large brand.

If you are a big brand, rivals and comparison sites already show up when people name you, so write hints that describe your own customers’ situations and keep your card in the running. If you are a small brand, comparison questions (“state farm vs allstate auto”) are winnable with a better card than a listicle. Never put a competitor’s name in your copy or hints. OpenAI’s ad policy allows only the trademarks you own or are authorized to use.

A stacked bar of 231 ad appearances on brand-naming prompts: 23 the brand’s own ad, 68 a rival carrier, 140 a third party; below it, four examples of who appeared most often
Name a brand, see its rivals. GEICO appeared most often on State Farm, Progressive and USAA prompts; BestMoney on Lemonade’s.

What do the prompts look like?

People ask full questions with their situation in them, not short keyword strings. gptadlibrary splits the insurance ads it recorded by question type: “best X for me” 20.2%, comparisons 15.0%, price 15.1%, long personal scenarios 14.9%, “fix or choose” 14.7%, “is it worth it” 10.1%, short searches 10.0%. The sample’s 1,279 prompts break down similarly: 267 best-for or cheapest prompts, 233 comparisons, 228 price prompts and 160 long scenarios of 18 words or more.

Long prompts carry the details: “I’m 27, got my license in Ohio last year and had one minor fender bender already.” “Lemonade auto home pet bundle, is it really cheaper or just marketed that way.” “Is Lemonade renters insurance legit, Reddit.”

That last one returned a Lemonade ad: “Best Renters Insurance, starting at $5/mo.” A trust question got a price answer. A card that answered the trust question would have fit better.

The prompts with no insurance word

328 of the 1,279 prompts used none of these words: insurance (and insure, insurer, insured), cover and coverage, policy, premium, quote, deductible, claim, liability, Medicare, annuity, warranty or underwriting. About 100 named an insurer instead (“is erie really cheaper than allstate”). The rest were about something else entirely.

Liberty Mutual’s “Switch and Save” appeared on “best phone deals 2026 with trade in.” GEICO appeared on “is Valvoline Prime worth it for someone who drives 15,000 miles a year.” Lemonade’s pet ads appeared on dog-vet and cat-feeder questions. ERGO NEXT’s general-liability certificate ad appeared on a question about cannabis-compliant soil testing labs.

A 15,000-mile driver is an auto prospect. A soil-testing lab is a stretch. The platform reads the situation, not just the word, so write hints for the situation. Chapter 4 shows how.

What insurance ads look like

Median headline: 25 characters. Median description: 54. 34% of creatives use a comparison word (compare, vs, best, top). 11.1% mention a price or a savings figure. 8.4% ask a question. About a third of media-brand creatives put the year in the headline; carriers almost never do. Nearly every card carries an image: 95% on gptadlibrary, 99% on chatgptadlibrary.

Ads Manager’s counter suggests 32 characters for the headline and 54 for the description, and warns past 32. On a small phone (360 pixels wide) the headline cuts near 24 characters and the description near 48. By that measure, 52% of insurance headlines and 54% of descriptions run past the cut. On a 390-pixel iPhone, about 30% of headlines still do. These are today’s numbers; OpenAI can change the card.

How to see what your competitors run in ChatGPT

  1. Start with the libraries. chatgptadlibrary.com, gptadlibrary.com and sprites.ai show real ad cards and the prompts they appeared on, and some show the landing page link. Their researchers write the prompts, so their counts do not show how often ChatGPT shows ads.
  2. Ask your customers’ questions yourself. Use ChatGPT signed out, and signed in on a Free account, on a phone and on a desktop. Plus, Pro, Business, Enterprise and Edu plans show no ads. Write down the date, the exact prompt, the advertiser and the card text. Open the card’s three-dot menu and read “About this ad.” OpenAI says the ad “matched the limited data that’s used to deliver you ads, like general location, context, and device type.” Keep it to a handful of real questions.
  3. Read the link instead of tapping. OpenAI’s Advertising Terms say advertisers will not “generate fraudulent, repetitive, or otherwise invalid clicks, impressions, queries, or other interactions.” On a phone, press and hold the card and copy the link. On a desktop, hover over the card to see it. Otherwise use the landing page link a library recorded.
  4. Open the landing page directly. Paste the address without its tracking parameters, so your visit does not land in their reports. Check whether the page repeats the ad’s promise, and what it asks for first.
  5. Don’t automate it, and don’t borrow names. OpenAI’s Terms of Use say you may not “Automatically or programmatically extract data or Output.” So no scripts, bots or scraping tools on ChatGPT. When you write your own ads, OpenAI’s ad policy says advertisers “may use only the trademarks, logos, brand assets, and other intellectual property they own or are authorized to use.” Learn from a rival’s card. Never put its name in your copy or hints.

One example: a Lemonade ad read “Best Dog Insurance. Help cover costly vet care,” and its landing page led with “Pet insurance with super fast everything.” The ad sells vet bills and the page sells speed. Keep your ad and your page on the same promise.

Research note

The advertising examples include 405 unique insurance creatives from three independent libraries (sprites.ai, chatgptadlibrary.com and gptadlibrary.com, June to October 2026) and a small set of direct ChatGPT observations in October 2026. The libraries’ researchers write the prompts. On gptadlibrary, each ad followed a request for a sponsored ad. A creative is one advertiser plus one headline. The samples show which ads appeared, not how often every advertiser appears or how well their campaigns convert.

The counts and classifications are licensed CC BY 4.0: reuse them with credit to Digital Star Marketing. The license does not cover the ads themselves.

Performance evidence is in Chapter 7.

FAQs

Is there an official ad library from OpenAI?

Not as of today. These three are among several independent libraries. The Brookings researchers also published their dataset.

How often do insurance prompts show an ad?

Nobody has a clean number. Studies range from 4.5% to 77% of prompts, with very different methods. One Australian vendor reported 71% on insurance queries over two days. In live answers in October, 16 of 22 showed an ad, and 5 of 10 first questions in a new chat did. Insurance seems to draw ads more than average.

Sources, checked October 27, 2026:

Want it run for you? Talk to an insurance marketer who runs ChatGPT ads.

Alex Moura
Written by

Alex Moura

Alex Moura is Co-Founder and CEO of Digital Star Marketing and a fractional CMO for insurtech and MGA teams, with hands-on experience in paid media and HubSpot attribution.

Make your ChatGPT ads count quotes, not clicks.

Tell us what lines you write and where you are licensed. Alex Moura will check your tracking, your quote form and your state plan, then map the first test with you.

Bobby Touran

★★★★★

“Digital Star is hands-on, creative and thoughtful at every step!”

Bobby Touran, CEO and Founder at Rainbow