Skip to content

Should your insurance business advertise in ChatGPT?

Alex Moura Co-Founder and CEO of Digital Star Marketing. Fractional CMO for insurtech and MGA teams, with hands-on experience in paid media and HubSpot attribution. Published · Updated
An independent insurance agency owner in his fifties stands in the doorway of his small storefront office on a main street, thinking. A small insurance team of three talks around a round table in a bright office, one gesturing with an open hand, paper notes between them.

If you sell policies to regular people, yes, test it. A quote form is the same kind of result as the sign-ups OpenAI shows off, and your test tells you whether it works as well for you. If you’re recruiting agents, try it at $25 a day. If you sell to carriers or distributors, wait. A lot of your buyers are on Plus, Business or Enterprise, which don’t show ads, and the two public B2B tests got zero qualified leads.

Who ChatGPT ads fit

Each of the three kinds of insurance business sells to a different kind of buyer, so each gets a different answer.

Three cards: selling policies, run it; recruiting agents, test it; selling to carriers and distributors, not yet
Who ChatGPT ads fit today.

Selling policies: run it

The questions that end in a quote are the ones insurers already bid on.

The largest public library logged 6,075 insurance ads across 6,163 conversations its researchers wrote, over seven question types: “best for” (20%), price (15%), comparison (15%), long personal scenarios (15%), “fix or choose” (15%), “is it worth it” (10%) and short searches (10%). Those shares show how the library wrote its prompts, not how often people ask. OpenAI publishes no volume data by category.

The conversion that follows is a form. Forms are what most of OpenAI’s published customer results measure. Jotform reports more than 10% of clicks became sign-ups at 60% lower cost than social and 30% lower than search. Angi reports cost per lead down 34% after switching to conversion bidding. LegalNature reports about 40% of visitors started a document and about 8% finished one.

Those are OpenAI’s numbers about its own customers. They are not a forecast for yours. But a renters quote is a lot closer to a Jotform sign-up than to a $40,000 software deal.

Start with one line of business, one state you are licensed in, two ads, and the Conversions objective, billed on impressions if your account offers it and on clicks if not. The setup is in Chapter 5.

Recruiting agents: test it

Producers do ask ChatGPT about carriers, commissions and appointments. No one has published a test of agent recruiting on the platform yet.

Hold it to a $25-a-day test against your own cost per appointed agent from Google Ads. That is the number a ChatGPT test has to beat or come close to.

OpenAI’s policy, clarified in August, bans ads for individual job listings. Point the ad at your agent program page, not one opening. Keep income promises out of the copy. The financial-services approval still applies, so expect the licensure check.

Selling to carriers and distributors: not yet

If your customer is a carrier, an MGA or a broker, many of the people who sign your contract use ChatGPT on Plus, Business or Enterprise. Those plans show no ads. Some still use the free plan, so you reach part of the buying team, not all of it.

The two independent B2B tests that published their numbers bear this out. Symphonic Digital spent about $500, got 53 clicks, 0 leads. Workshop Digital spent $2,319, got 739 clicks at $3.14 each, 0 qualified leads, while its Google Search campaigns produced 2 in the same period.

OpenAI’s own B2B story, Stream, reports a 2x return on ad spend selling APIs to developers. That is a vendor-published result, and developers are not insurance executives. Treat it as a sign a B2B test is possible, not a reason to expect one to work.

Spend the money on being the answer instead. When a VP of distribution asks ChatGPT which policy-admin vendors serve MGAs, you want to be named in the answer. No ad budget buys that. Six steps to getting recommended covers how.

The life moments that create an insurance need

Brookings published the full dataset behind its audit: 3,602 ads, 191 advertisers, collected March 8 to April 12, 2026.

It contains no insurance advertisers, because OpenAI’s policy kept financial-services ads out at launch, and it only began opening to them in April and May, as the study ended.

Prompt topicAds shownWho showed up
Car questions (“how do I replace a car battery”)187Advance Auto Parts 93, GM certified service, Harbor Freight
Buying a home41Realtor.com 35, Zillow 5
Renting15Rent.com 11, Realtor.com 3
“I’m so thrilled about buying my first house!”7Realtor.com, Forbes, CustomInk, Dollar General

A first car, apartment or house is where policies get bought. In spring 2026 the brands in those conversations sold parts and listings.

An insurer that describes those situations in its context hints, instead of the word insurance, can show up there. Some insurers already show up on such prompts. In the 405-ad sample, a quarter of the prompts that triggered an insurer’s ad used no insurance word. Some were not about insurance at all. GEICO showed up on a question about motor oil.

In live tests in October, three life-moment questions with no insurance word (moving to a new apartment, buying a used car, adopting a dog) drew no insurer’s ad. On moving and on the used car, ChatGPT itself told the person to get insurance and named no insurer. In the moving chat, an insurance ad appeared only after “renters insurance” came up. These moments are still open to insurers and worth testing.

What about health insurance and Medicare?

Approved US advertisers can run health insurance ads. OpenAI keeps ads away from personal health conversations.

The place a health plan most wants to appear is the place the platform will not put it. General coverage questions may still carry ads. Medicare Advantage ads also fall under CMS marketing rules. A third-party marketing organization (TPMO) may need CMS’s disclaimer on its marketing, landing page included, and the required wording depends on its role and the organizations it represents. Marketing that mentions benefits or premiums generally goes to CMS through HPMS, submitted by the plan or, under specific conditions, by a qualifying TPMO. Confirm both with compliance before the ad runs. Wait on health. Let the platform prove itself on a property or auto line first.

FAQs

We sell both policies and B2B software. Where do we start?

With the policies. Run the consumer test first and learn what a quote costs. Keep the B2B budget on organic AI visibility. Revisit when a B2B test in your space shows qualified leads.

Our agency recruits in 20 states. Can we test in all of them?

Test in one or two. A $25-a-day budget spread across 20 states learns nothing. Pick the states with the most open appointments and the cleanest tracking, and widen on day 15.

Should we run ChatGPT ads if ChatGPT already names us in the answer?

Check first. Ask your brand prompts signed out, on a phone. If ChatGPT names you and a rival or a comparison site buys the card underneath, the ad defends the click. If no ad shows under your brand prompts, spend on comparison and life-moment prompts instead.

What if our buyers are independent agents on the free plan?

Then they can see the ad, and the recruiting verdict applies: test it. Describe the appointment, the lines and the states in your hints, and count applications, not clicks.

Sources, checked October 27, 2026:

Want it run for you? Talk to an insurance marketer who runs ChatGPT ads.

Alex Moura
Written by

Alex Moura

Alex Moura is Co-Founder and CEO of Digital Star Marketing and a fractional CMO for insurtech and MGA teams, with hands-on experience in paid media and HubSpot attribution.

Make your ChatGPT ads count quotes, not clicks.

Tell us what lines you write and where you are licensed. Alex Moura will check your tracking, your quote form and your state plan, then map the first test with you.

Bobby Touran

★★★★★

“Digital Star is hands-on, creative and thoughtful at every step!”

Bobby Touran, CEO and Founder at Rainbow